Flu Test: Rapid Results vs. Accuracy (Rapid Antigen Test vs. PCR)

Flu Test

Identifying the Cause: Making an Influenza Diagnosis

Influenza, which is also referred to as the flu, is a virus-induced respiratory disease. Although symptoms such as fever, cough, and exhaustion may be suggestive, a precise diagnosis is essential for effective treatment and management of infections. This article examines the three primary techniques for influenza diagnosis: viral culture, polymerase chain reaction (PCR), and fast antigen testing.

Thank you for reading this post, don't forget to subscribe!

1. Rapid Antigen Tests (RIDTs): Limited Scope, Fast Results
Point-of-care diagnostics called rapid antigen testing (RIDTs) provide a rapid and easy means of identifying influenza infection. They function by detecting particular viral proteins, or antigens, in a respiratory sample, usually a swab taken from the nose.

Benefits of RIDTs:

• Quick findings: RIDTs can yield results in ten to fifteen minutes, enabling prompt treatment decisions.
• Convenience: Depending on the particular RIDT, these tests are frequently conducted in clinics, physician offices, and even at home.
• Cost-effective: Compared to other diagnostic techniques, RIDTs are typically less expensive.

RIDT drawbacks include:

Flu Test

• Reduced accuracy: RIDTs are less sensitive than PCR and viral culture, which means that some influenza infections may go unnoticed, especially in the early stages of the illness.
• Limited differentiation: The ability to differentiate between influenza A and B viruses, which is crucial for treatment and public health monitoring, is not present in the majority of RIDTs.

When do RIDTs make the most sense?

Flu Test

For those with flu-like symptoms who want a quick diagnosis, RIDTs are a useful choice, particularly if the illness occurs during the busiest part of the flu season. They are also useful in places like emergency rooms or urgent care centres when prompt decision-making is required.

2. Polymerase Chain Reaction (PCR): Extended Wait, High Accuracy
The extremely sensitive and specific polymerase chain reaction (PCR) assay can identify influenza viral genetic material (RNA) in respiratory samples. It increases the amount of viral RNA in the sample, making it possible to identify even minute levels of the virus.

Benefits of PCR:

Flu Test

High accuracy: PCR produces more dependable results than RIDTs since it has a higher sensitivity and specificity.
distinguishes between influenza kinds Certain PCR tests can distinguish between the influenza A and B viruses, which can help with trend analysis and therapy selection.

The drawbacks of PCR

• Longer turnaround time: PCR findings can take several hours to a day, depending on the lab, even if they are faster than viral culture.
• Needs specialised tools and knowledge Typically, PCR testing is carried out in specialised labs by qualified staff members.
• Cost: Compared to RIDTs, PCR testing is typically more expensive.

When are PCR testing the most suitable?

Flu Test

For people who have a strong suspicion of having the flu, PCR is recommended, particularly when:

• Although RIDTs are negative, clinical suspicion is still quite high.
• To help with treatment decisions, hospitalisation is required.
• The particular strain of influenza that is circulating in the community must be identified by public health professionals.

3. Viral Culture: Time-consuming, but the gold standard
Influenza diagnosis via viral culture is the conventional approach and is regarded as the “gold standard.” It entails gathering a respiratory sample and injecting it into specialised lab cell cultures. The presence of influenza virus will cause it to proliferate inside the cells, proving the diagnosis.

Benefits of the Viral Culture:

Flu Test

• Verifies virus viability: The presence of a viable influenza virus is confirmed by viral culture, which enables more in-depth strain characterisation.
• Research-useful: Viral isolates from cultures can be utilised to investigate antiviral resistance and create vaccines.

Negative aspects of viral culture

• Slowest turnaround time: A virus’s ability to develop in culture can take several days, which can cause delays in diagnosis and treatment choices.
• Needs specific labs and knowledge Trained staff and specialised lab space are needed for viral culture.
• Cost: Viral culture can be more expensive than RIDTs, much like PCR.

When is the best time to use viral culture?

The main circumstances in which viral culture is employed are:

• Further testing has not shown a definite diagnosis.
• There may be novel or uncommon influenza strains.
• For scientific purposes, virus isolates are required.

Selecting the Appropriate Diagnostic Test: A Physician’s Choice

Flu Test
The selection of an influenza diagnostic test is contingent upon multiple factors, such as:

• The degree of symptom severity
• The medical background of the patient
• When sickness occurs in relation to influenza season
• The availability of many techniques of testing

Flu Test
It’s crucial to speak with your physician to find out which diagnostic test is best for your particular circumstances. In addition to greatly improving your prognosis, prompt diagnosis and early treatment can stop the influenza virus from spreading to other people.